The six grades

The condition options on the listing form depend on the category, and picking the right one is part of eBay's selling practices policy.[1] In 2025 eBay split the single Pre-owned grade for clothing into Excellent, Good and Fair.[2]

Decision flow. Look at the garment in good light. Question 1: never worn at all? If yes, choose New with tags, New without tags, or New with imperfections. Question 2: heavy wear, or missing or damaged parts? If yes, Pre-owned - Fair. Question 3: light wear or any visible flaw? If yes, Pre-owned - Good. Otherwise, with little to no signs of wear, Pre-owned - Excellent. In every case, photograph and describe each flaw.
Pick a grade in three questions. Built from eBay's grade definitions.[2][1] Checking the worst grade first is our method, so heavy flaws are never missed.

Old listings were moved to Good

When the change took effect, existing Pre-owned clothing listings were set to Pre-owned - Good automatically. eBay recommends moving items that are really Fair, to avoid not-as-described returns.[2]

Write the condition description

A simplified sketch of the condition part of a listing, not eBay's design. Callout 1: the condition grade, for example Pre-owned - Good; buyers filter search results by condition. Callout 2: the condition description names each flaw and where it is, for example light pilling under the arms and a small mark on the left cuff, shown in photo 6. Callout 3: the photos include a close-up of every imperfection described.
Where the flaw details go. Based on eBay's developer guide to item conditions[3] and its help page; the wording in row 2 is an example.[1]

eBay's developer guide puts extra condition detail in a separate condition description, up to 1000 characters, rather than in the main description.[3] For brand-new conditions, that field is ignored.[3]

eBay notes that buyers may read the same condition name differently from one category to another.[3] Naming each flaw and its place removes the guesswork. Good flaw photos matter too; see how many photos to use.[1]

Why the grade matters

Buyers often narrow searches by condition, and an inaccurate grade can be filtered out of those searches.[3][2] eBay also warns it can lead to more returns and negative feedback, which can affect your seller standards.[2]

Under the eBay Money Back Guarantee, a buyer can open a claim up to 30 days after delivery, or within your return window if that is longer.[4] Sellers must deliver the item as described in the listing.[4]

Shoes use different names

eBay's help page still lists New with defects for shoes, where clothing now says New with imperfections.[1] New shoes with no signs of wear that have lost their box count as New without box.[1]

For the details shoe buyers filter on, see item specifics for shoes. For measuring garments, see how to measure clothing.

Before you choose a grade

  • Check the garment in good light, inside and out, for every flaw.[1]
  • Worn at all? Pick Excellent, Good or Fair by how much wear shows.[2]
  • Name each flaw and where it is in the condition description.[3]
  • Photograph every imperfection you describe.[1]
  • Review older listings that were moved to Pre-owned - Good automatically.[2]

Questions sellers also ask

What is the difference between Pre-owned Excellent and Good?

Excellent means little to no signs of wear; Good means gently used, with light signs of wear and/or visible flaws.[2]

Can a buyer return a used item if I don't accept returns?

Yes, if it does not match the listing: the eBay Money Back Guarantee still applies.[4]

Is New with imperfections for worn items?

No. It is for items that have never been worn but have some kind of defect.[1]

References

  1. eBay. (n.d.). Item condition by category. Official help
    https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/listings/creating-managing-listings/item-conditions-category?id=4765 (accessed 22 November 2026)
  2. eBay Seller Center. (n.d.). Introducing new conditions for pre-loved clothing. Official blog
    https://www.ebay.com/sellercenter/resources/seller-updates/2025-january/new-item-conditions (accessed 22 November 2026)
  3. eBay Developers Program. (n.d.). Item conditions. Official help
    https://developer.ebay.com/api-docs/user-guides/static/trading-user-guide/item-conditions.html (accessed 22 November 2026)
  4. eBay. (n.d.). eBay Money Back Guarantee policy. Official policy
    https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/ebay-money-back-guarantee-policy/ebay-money-back-guarantee-policy?id=4210 (accessed 22 November 2026)

How this page was made: every factual sentence carries a numbered reference to a source we read on the date shown. Platform rules change, so check the official page before you act on a deadline or a fee. Forum threads are marked anecdotal and are used only to show what sellers report. See how we research.